News Article

Cost Of Ownership Dictates New MOCVD Reactor Design

Throughput, yield and the deposition of expensive metal-organic precursors dominate the cost of ownership of MOCVD reactors, according to research at Aixtron. Rainer Beccard explains how these three factors have driven the design of the company's latest planetary reactor.
During the last 20 years the MOCVD process has matured from a technique used in
research laboratories to a common method for manufacturing high volumes of compound
semiconductor devices.

The driving force for new developments has also moved on from its original form, which
was to demonstrate the suitability of an MOCVD process for a specific device. Today
manufacturers employing MOCVD technology are concerned with high-volume
manufacturing, and use multiwafer platforms such as Aixtron's planetary reactors to
carry out simultaneous epitaxial growth on several substrates. This technique produces
large quantities of epiwafers with good uniformity and has enabled the expansion of the
LED manufacturing industry.

The industry is now entering a third stage of development that reflects the maturity of
both MOCVD and LED technology. The focus is directed at reducing manufacturing
costs, so that LED makers can achieve profitable margins despite the year-on-year falls in
the average selling price of their devices. Since the MOCVD process is one of the key
manufacturing steps, cutting costs here can reduce the cost of ownership (CoO) of an
MOCVD reactor.

Aixtron has redeveloped its planetary reactor mass-production platforms to reduce the
CoO of these systems. This approach has been applied to reactors for both GaInN-based
blue, green and white LEDs, and AlGaInP-based red and yellow LEDs. There is much
interest in red LEDs owing to their expected application in red, green and blue (RGB)
backlighting systems for large LCD screens.

The design process began with an investigation of the CoO of existing reactors, using
standards defined by the Semiconductor Equipment and Materials International
organization. Calculations revealed that the key parameters were throughput, yield and
the deposition efficiency of costly metal-organic precursors.

After defining a CoO target value, a detailed theoretical study of reactor and MOCVD
system configurations was undertaken, including comprehensive numerical modeling of
the reactor geometry. These efforts led to a reactor design that delivered CoO
improvements verified by actual growth runs.

Increasing wafer coverage

Throughput is defined by the reactor's load capacity, the wafer size, and the time taken
for a complete growth cycle.

Today most LED manufacturers work with 2 inch substrates, despite the promises of
higher yield, reduced edge effects and greater wafer area offered by 4 inch material.
Consequently, the reactor had to be designed for both 2 inch and 4 inch processes. The reactor geometry also had to optimize the growth area, which resulted in a design suitable
for either a 12 × 4 inch or 49 × 2 inch configuration, and with a total wafer area of 150 inch2. This represented an increase of 50% and 40% on the standard platforms of 8 × 4  inch and 35 × 2 inch, respectively.

To optimize throughput it is also necessary to minimize growth cycle times, which are a
combination of the time taken for material growth, the loading and unloading of wafers,
and the heating and cooling of the reactor. This was partly accomplished by introducing a
novel automated handling system to load and unload at high temperatures, which
eliminated the time lost while the reactor cooled down. Although automatic loading has
already been used for GaAs/AlGaAs-based HEMT and HBT processes, a refined version
has been developed that is suitable for the much thicker AlGaAs/AlGaInP/GaP LED

Another approach to reducing growth cycle times was to develop a reactor that could
produce the same material quality more quickly. Previously, growth rates were limited by
parasitic reactions that occurred before the gases reached the wafer surface, an effect that
is more likely at higher precursor concentrations.

The second criterion that strongly impacts the CoO is yield, which can be considered
either in terms of epiwafers or LED chips, although the latter are more appropriate as
they are related to the final product. The MOCVD process influences the uniformity of
LED properties on each wafer and from wafer to wafer. Efforts were directed to optimize
the uniformity of film thickness, layer composition and doping for both 2 inch and 4 inch

The third factor controlling CoO is the growth efficiency of the relatively expensive
metal-organic precursors that are used for the epitaxial process. Efficiency was defined as
the ratio of group III atoms incorporated into the grown layers to the number of group III
atoms entering the reactor through the metal-organic sources.

Optimizing the reactor's growth efficiency for novel geometries is a time-consuming
process that has to take into account details relating to both reactor hardware and process
parameters. High efficiencies are frequently achieved by adjusting the parameters that
also affect film thickness uniformity, so the solution must balance optimizing the
efficiency while ensuring high levels of uniformity for all relevant materials within the
LED structure.

The novel reactor design is based on Aixtron's earlier 2600 planetary platforms but uses
different hardware including an improved gas inlet geometry. Measurements of
composition and thickness on all of the materials used to produce red and yellow LEDs
(GaAs, AlGaAs, AlGaInP, GaInP and GaP) verified that the reactor's growth process
fulfilled the theoretical predictions. The reactor's capability was assessed for both the 12 × 4 inch and 49 × 2 inch configurations, and the effect of the standard p- and n-type dopants, tellurium and magnesium. Results revealed that the reactor can meet and even surpass the typical epiwafer specifications for doping uniformity, thickness and so on demanded for LED production.

LEDs contain distributed Bragg reflectors - alternating GaAs and AlGaAs layers - that
reduce light loss into the substrate. The thickness uniformity of these layers is revealed
by their reflectivity profiles (figure 1). Uniformities across a 4 inch wafer and between
wafers from the same growth run are better than 0.5%, assuming an edge exclusion zone
of 3 mm, showing that the process is suitable for producing LED material.

Although the growth and uniformity of GaAs and AlGaAs layers depend predominantly
on the reactor's flow dynamics, other LED materials such as AlGaInP are more
temperature dependent. Consequently a large-scale reactor's temperature uniformity can
be revealed through the growth of AlGaInP layers. Epiwafers produced on a 12 × 4 inch platform show typical photoluminescence (PL) uniformities of less than 0.45 nm (3 mm edge excluded) and a wafer-to-wafer variation below 0.8 nm, indicating excellent growth temperature homogeneity (figure 2).

Aixtron's reactor is also suited to high epiwafer yields using the 49 × 2 inch configuration. PL on-wafer uniformities of 0.53 nm (3 mm edge excluded) and wafer-to-wafer uniformities of 0.78 mm were achieved from a full load of wafers containing an AlGaInP multiple quantum well active region emitting at 630 nm.

The growth efficiencies of the metal-organic materials used in LEDs were determined for
both 12 × 4 inch and 49 × 2 inch reactor configurations (table 1).These efficiencies, which are delivered without compromising material uniformity, are 20% higher than those achieved with the 8 × 4 inch and 35 × 2 inch standard configuration. This improved performance results from the optimization of the gas inlet and the susceptor geometry.

The CoO of the new reactor will be reduced even more through faster growth rates.
Although faster growth rates can deteriorate material quality, the very high precursor
efficiency and the minimization of parasitic reactions through optimized design of the
reactor chamber and the gas inlet were expected to enable rapid growth of high-quality

X-ray diffraction and electrical characterization measurements revealed no loss of film
quality, despite an increase in the growth rate of AlGaInP and GaAs from 1.5 μm/h and 2 μm/h to 4.3 μm/h and 16.7 μm/h, respectively. These significant increases indicate the huge potential for additional cuts in growth time that will lead to lower production costs.

These new 12 × 4 inch or 49 × 2 inch planetary reactors, which are suitable for red and yellow LED production, satisfy the requirements for high-quality material and meet well defined CoO targets. This design, which is also suitable for solar cell or laser manufacturing, reflects the growing level of maturity within the III-V industry.

CS International to return to Brussels – bigger and better than ever!

The leading global compound semiconductor conference and exhibition will once again bring together key players from across the value chain for two-days of strategic technical sessions, dynamic talks and unrivalled networking opportunities.

Join us face-to-face between 28th – 29th June 2022

  • View the agenda.
  • 3 for the price of 1. Register your place and gain complementary access to TWO FURTHER industry leading conferences: PIC International and SSI International.
  • Email  or call +44 (0)24 7671 8970 for more details.

*90% of exhibition space has gone - book your booth before it’s too late!


Search the news archive

To close this popup you can press escape or click the close icon.
Register - Step 1

You may choose to subscribe to the Compound Semiconductor Magazine, the Compound Semiconductor Newsletter, or both. You may also request additional information if required, before submitting your application.

Please subscribe me to:


You chose the industry type of "Other"

Please enter the industry that you work in:
Please enter the industry that you work in:
Live Event