Disinfecting COVID cough spray with UV-C
Italian researchers show that UV-C radiation can reduce contamination risk by about 50 percent when irradiating saliva droplet clouds
One of the primary ways the COVID-19 virus is transmitted is via airborne diffusion of saliva microdroplets, so it is paramount to find methods to kill the virus in airborne microdroplets. Researchers in Italy have explored deactivating the virus particles via UV-C light by numerical modeling of saliva droplets produced by coughs,
The Marche Polytechnic University researchers were inspired by the early confusion in the pandemic about safe social distances, mask wearing, and social behaviour. They wanted to find answers and ways to help.
In Physics of Fluids, from AIP Publishing, Valerio D'Alessandro and colleagues describe using a supercomputer to do numerical modelling of cough droplets irradiated by UV-C light. They also report exploring the social distances required to prevent virus transmission.
The researchers zeroed in on the evolution of a saliva droplet cloud, accounting for the inertia, buoyancy, and weight of each droplet and its aerodynamic interaction with the environment.
"We are interested in the possibility of deactivating virus particles via UV-C light," D'Alessandro said. "So, we explored the interaction of saliva droplets with an external source of UV-C radiation, a lamp."
UV-C is a well-established germicidal technique, because it interferes with virus RNA replication. Moreover, it's hoped that UV-C LEDs will be able to provide compact, low cost technology for this kind of disinfection.
"UV-A and UV-B also kill germs and are present within the sun's rays, but with these, it takes 15 to 20 minutes to kill a virus," said D'Alessandro. "The sun's rays disinfect surfaces during the summer, which is one reason why transmission is reduced then, but it can't be used for real-time disinfection. That's why we decided to explore the effect of UV-C radiation on viruses."
The researchers' work addresses key points still not completely understood. First, they determined that 1 metre (3.2 feet) of social distancing is not completely safe to avoid virus transmission. This is particularly important, because this is the social distancing rule in Italy and its schools.
"While 1 metre of distance can suffice in a one-on-one situation, you can still get hit with cough droplets from the chest down," D'Alessandro said. "It's necessary to avoid touching your eyes, nose, or mouth with your hands. We found 2 metres (6.5 feet) to be a much safer distance."
In the picture above, the red zone (from your chest down) is the area of highest risk, so while your face may only receive a few cough droplets, it is critical to wash your hands and keep them away from your face.
D'Alessandro and colleagues stress that the largest droplets travel about 1 metre. Over this distance they discovered only smaller droplets, which transport a reduced amount of the virus.
"It's important to emphasise that these results were obtained without any background wind, and if this is present, the distance is almost doubled," he said. "So we need to wear face masks, especially when in close proximity."
They also found "it is possible to reduce the contamination risk by about 50 percent when irradiating saliva droplet clouds with UV-C radiation - without providing a dangerous dose to people," said D'Alessandro. "This is critically important, because disinfection systems based on UV-C are not always acceptable. UV-C kills the virus, but higher doses for humans can be dangerous."
High exposures to UV-C are known to cause skin and eye tumours.
"Our work helps correct the understanding of safe social distancing," said D'Alessandro. "Also, our computations can help to design new real-time disinfection devices based on UV-C that can reduce the risk of COVID-19 transmission and other viruses within particular situations, such as for supermarket cashiers or people in similar situations."
'Eulerian-Lagrangian modeling of cough droplets irradiated by ultraviolet-C light in relation to SARS-CoV-2 transmission' by V. D'Alessandroet al: Physics of Fluids on March 9, 2021