GaN In Power Electronics Applications
Many studies have shown the direct relationship between energy and Gross Domestic Product (GDP). This seems entirely plausible since a growing economy entails more production, as well as increasing levels of consumption.
Policy makers in countries around the globe are realizing that a future overwhelmingly dependent on carbon-based sources of energy is likely to put the brakes on growth as these energy resources become scarcer and more expensive. Figure 1 shows how closely energy consumption trends track GDP.
Figure 1: Global GDP Growth vs. Energy Consumption Growth
Source: The Shift Project
As regional and global economies grow, they are also becoming “digital". This means there is much more reliance on electronic data and devices by consumers, enterprises and governments in the course of normal activities. For these devices and networks to function reliably, electric grid networks must be upgraded and expanded where they exist and built out where the networks donot exist. A robust, efficient grid is necessary to ensure growth, while minimizing the amount of energy required to meet these demands.
These requirements have provided the impetus for the growth of the power electronics industry. To sustain growth in the face of shrinking supplies of fossil fuel sources and minimize the byproducts of these fuels, countries are turning to alternative energy sources, along with replacement technologies. In addition to finding alternative sources to generate electricity and minimize fossil fuel consumption, development efforts are underway to increase the efficiency of components in devices and the electrical grid.
The power electronics or power management market addresses electronic components used in the efficient delivery of electrical power to the end user. Typical applications include DC-DC and AC-DC power conversion for consumer devices such as PCs, cellular handsets and power supplies.
The increasing consumption of data by enterprises and cloud storage is driving the need for high performance servers and server arrays. Applications requiring much higher power handling include inverters used to convert DC power into AC for grid connectivity and electric motor drives used in electric and hybrid electric vehicles (HEVs), as well as a number of other applications.
Any power management technology incurs loss when converting current. With the growing emphasis on energy efficiency and renewable energy sources, there is a strengthening demand for devices that optimize the efficiency of this conversion, even if by only a few percent. The migration towards micro-generation of energy through a distributed grid, with production on a much smaller scale will require large numbers of inverter modules and systems to feed the electricity into the grid as efficiently as possible.
In addition to the benefits of a future that is not so dependent on fossil fuels, the electric grid provides an enormous opportunity. The U.S. electric grid, alone is estimated to contain more than 200,000 miles of high-voltage transmission lines and 5.5 million miles of local distribution lines, connecting many thousands of generating power plants to factories, homes and businesses1.
Various estimates place the size of the global semiconductor device market (discrete devices, ICs and modules) for power electronics applications at somewhere between $15 billion and $20 billion dollars in 2012! This value is expected to grow in the future as power generation sources increase, companies become more conscious of energy consumption and the usage of consumer devices continues to increase quickly.
Currently, the power management device market is dominated by silicon MOSFETs and IGBTs, technologies that replaced the vacuum tubes of the 1940 and 1950s. There is still a lot of development activity aimed at improving the performance of devices using these technologies.
There is also a growing concern that these legacy technologies will not support the anticipated evolution of the grid. In some applications, requirements for blocking voltages, switching frequencies and efficiency already exceed the capability of silicon-based devices.
With this as the backdrop, wide bandgap materials, primarily GaN and SiC are generating significant interest. The hope is devices using these materials will increase the efficiency and the reliability of the electric grid as it evolves. The electrical properties of these materials should enable higher switching frequencies, higher blocking voltages, lower switching losses, better thermal conductivity and higher operating temperatures.
At present, SiC is farther along than GaN for these high power electronics applications. In the near term, Strategy Analytics expects SiC to be the primary replacement technology for silicon power devices, while GaN seeks initial commercial traction in applications with breakdown voltages of less than < 600V and power requirements of less than 5kW.
Generic advantages of wide bandgap materials over silicon in power electronics device applications include:
· Lower on-resistances, which result in lower conductivity losses and higher overall efficiency
· Higher breakdown voltages:available Si Schottky diodes have breakdown voltage up to 300V, the first commercial SiC Schottky diodes are rated at 600V
· Higher thermal conductivity compared to Si: this leads to a lower junction-to-case thermal resistance, allowing more efficient heat transfer
· Higher temperature operation: SiC devices can operate up to 600°C, while Si devices can operate at a maximum junction temperature of only 150°C
· Forward and reverse characteristics that vary only slightly with temperature and time
· Lower reverse recovery current, reducing switching losses and electromagnetic interference (EMI)
· Operation at frequencies >20 kHz, which is not possible with Si-based devices at power levels of more than a few tens of kilowatts
· Higher voltage input/output ratios that allow a single stage for DC-DC conversion from 48V to 1V, compared with a silicon power MOSFET converter that would normally require two or more stages
Initially, GaN-based devices seemed a likely fit for applications where the high voltage and power handling capability, coupled with conversion efficiencies than were higher than the silicon equivalents, would create a high-value niche. The advantages of wide bandgap materials for power electronics applications have partly been borne out by the deployment of SiC devices in hybrid electric vehicles, but the penetration of GaN-based power devices may be more likely in lower-voltage applications, where SiC is proving to be too expensive.
In the power management segment, power conversion applications offer the greatest potential for GaN. These applications typically require fast, efficient switches, where the higher carrier mobility inherent to GaN transistors is advantageous. While silicon devices are widely regarded to be at or approaching their performance limits, GaN offers opportunity for improvement, particularly in form factor and electrical efficiency.
A key figure of merit used in power management applications is the combination of on-resistance and switching speed. There is a lot of development underway to improve the performance of GaN FET devices. Figure 2 shows the Ron performance for two GaN devices from EPC Corporation. It is evident from the curves that the GaN devices maintain lower on-resistance for a given breakdown voltage versus the silicon MOSFET devices listed. The chart also shows that the theoretical maximum performance for GaN devices is superior to SiC.
Figure 2: Resistance versus Breakdown Voltage
The advantage goes beyond the on-resistance, however. The gate charge required to switch a GaN FET is much lower than that of a silicon device. The product of on-resistance and gate charge is a useful figure of merit for power transistors. A lower figure indicates a low resistance to turn-on, combined with a fast switching speed. As shown in Figure 3, EPC Corporation claims their GaN devices have an RQ product more than 10 times lower than silicon alternatives.
Figure 3: “RQ" Product Comparison: GaN vs. Silicon MOSFET
Source: EPC Corporation
EPC Corporation is one of the leading proponents of GaN for power management applications, and they make a compelling case for this technology. In Figure 4, they illustrate the theoretical performance comparison for GaN technology versus the incumbent silicon MOSFET technology and SiC technology.
Figure 4: Theoretical “RQ" Performance
Source: EPC Corporation
In practice, a low RQ figure of merit means that circuit designers do not have to sacrifice low on-resistance for fast switching, as is normally the case. A side benefit of this performance is that GaN DC-DC converter devices will operate at higher bandwidths. Silicon power MOSFETs have difficulty with pulse widths below 100ns (corresponding to a 250 KHz bandwidth), while GaN FETs can be turned on or off in as little as 4ns. Figure 5 summarizes these metrics with the performance of an EPC GaN device versus some representative silicon MOSFET devices. Note that the “RQ" product of the GaN device is almost an order of magnitude lower than best MOSFET.
Figure 5: “RQ" Product Comparison: GaN vs. Silicon MOSFET
Source: EPC Corporation
The implication is that a point-of-load (POL) converter using GaN can convert from 48V to 1V in a single stage, while an equivalent silicon converter would typically require one stage to convert to 12V and a second stage to convert to 1V. At higher drain-source voltages, the superiority of GaN becomes even more apparent, enabling entirely new architectures in power management, according to proponents such as EPC and International Rectifier.
In the past several years, there has been a concerted effort to develop enhancement-mode (normally off) GaN transistors, especially for power management applications. These enhancement-mode devices are attractive for these applications because they operate in a similar fashion to the incumbent MOSFET technology, but have much better performance characteristics.
A number of Japanese companies, including Sanken Electric, a collaboration between Fuji and Furukawa Electric, Panasonic and NEC, have all invested in the development of E-mode GaN HEMTs. In March 2010, Efficient Power Conversion (EPC) Corporation introduced a number of E-mode GaN-on-silicon power management devices, branded as eGaN, which they continue to refine and improve.
These E-mode devices have different driver requirements than their depletion-mode GaN and silicon MOSFET counterparts. Companies like National Semiconductor and Texas Instruments have developed lines of compatible drivers for E-mode GaN devices. These driver efforts are likely to speed adoption of E-mode GaN devices by making the final package of driver and transistor as easy to use as MOSFET devices.
For all the inherent material and performance advantages, developers of GaN transistor technology continue to address a number of challenges. The lack of suitable native GaN substrates complicates production of GaN devices because it is very difficult to grow lattice-matched, defect-free epilayers analogous to the processes used for GaAs or silicon transistor fabrication. There is substantial activity using a hydride vapor phase epitaxy (HVPE) method to produce thick layers that can serve as quasi-bulk substrates.
Shortfalls with this technique have given rise to development of ammonothermal growth techniques. In August 2012, Soraa, a developer of GaN-on-GaN solid-state lighting technology, was selected by Advanced Research Projects Agency-Energy (ARPA-E) to lead a project on the development of bulk GaN substrates.
The attraction of native GaN substrates lies in an anticipated performance improvement that may result in significant energy savings for LEDs. The LED market can provide the high-volume pull to develop a technology that can benefit other market segments with the availability of native GaN substrates.
Even with a production ready process, GaN substrates are not expected to compete with silicon substrates purely on wafer cost. However, proponents of native GaN substrates point out that a simplified process will result in cost savings that may make the product cost more manageable.
In the absence of production-scale, single-crystal GaN wafers, manufacturers must instead use foreign host materials such as sapphire, SiC or silicon. To date, semi-insulating SiC has been the material of choice for microelectronic components, thanks to its relatively close lattice match to GaN and its excellent thermal conductivity properties. However, the quality of epitaxial layers depends on both the lattice-match and the underlying substrate quality.
Historically, suppliers of semi-insulating SiC have struggled to produce material with defect density levels comparable to substrates such as silicon or GaAs. More recently, improvements to semi-insulating SiC material quality, along with the availability of larger substrates, have made SiC a more viable economic choice for GaN growth. This has helped to improve the reliability of GaN microelectronic devices. However, SiC remains a difficult and expensive material to produce and it provides cost challenges for cost-sensitive, high-volume applications.
In recent years, high-resistivity (HR) silicon has become a viable alternative to SiC in certain applications. Although it does not have as close a lattice match with GaN and possesses poorer thermal properties, silicon can offer a lower-cost path for some applications.
GaN-on-Si also shows potential to transition to high-volume manufacturing processes because it is amenable to existing CMOS (Complementary Metal-Oxide-Semiconductor) semiconductor fabrication technology using commercially available, large diameter silicon wafers. There is a lot of development work in this area with manufacturers like AZZURRO Semiconductors developing 150mm GaN-on-silicon wafers with a roadmap to 300mm diameter wafers in the future.
The size of the power electronics component market and the perceived advantages of wide bandgap technologies are leading to significant process and product development efforts. The US government realizes the importance of improvements in the efficiency and reliability of the electrical grid network and the US Department of Energy’s Office of Electricity Delivery and Energy Reliability (OE) has requested slightly more than $169 million in the FY2014 US budget to address issues and developments in this area. The budget request is up nearly 25% from 2012 spending as the OE recognizes the importance of the topic and realizes that industry will need some help to enable significant advances.
In April 2011, the OE released their “Power Electronics Research and Development Program Plan" that details the vision, activities, challenges, needs and partnership strategies for this market segment. The activities focus clearly on wide bandgap materials, with a heavy emphasis on developing and refining GaN-on-silicon processes and devices. By 2016, the program hopes to have GaN-on-silicon devices operating at 5kV and 15A performance levels, with a goal of 20kV and 50A device performance by 2026.
It appears clear that increasing demands for energy and an emphasis on alternative energy sources will lead to a very large market opportunity for power electronics components.
The advantages of wide bandgap technologies appear very compelling, but there are challenges that must be addressed before these technologies will displace incumbent silicon technologies with any sort of production scale. The promising development for GaN usage in this market segment is that industry and government agencies are recognizing the importance of this technology and devoting significant resources to technology and process development.
Considering all these factors, we estimate revenues for GaN devices used in power electronics applications will grow strongly, reaching slightly more than $73 million in 2017. While this revenue level represents only a very small portion of the total high power electronics market, the CAAGR (Compounded Average Annual Growth Rate) for GaN technology will be greater than 108%, indicating the revenue will roughly double every year, on average. GaN technology usage is in its infancy for high power electronics applications and we anticipate continued strong growth throughout the decade. Figure 6 shows this estimate.
Figure 6: GaN Device Revenue in High Power Electronics Applications
Increasing energy consumption, the shift to a “digital economy" and the evolution to more efficient, more distributed sources of energy generation will all increase the available market for power electronics devices. The incumbent technology is silicon IGBTs and MOSFETS, but there are concerns that the limitations of these devices and technologies will hamper the growth and refinement of the electric grid. Wide bandgap materials, most notably SiC and GaN offer promising performance advantages and these technologies are generating a lot of interest. Both these technologies have challenges to overcome and while SiC devices have made early advances, we believe GaN-on-silicon products will grow quickly to reach slightly more than $73 million in revenue in 2017.
Author : Eric Higham - Director - GaAs Strategic Technologies Practice
1Jennifer Weeks and The Daily Climate, “U.S. Electrical Grid Undergoes Massive Transition to Connect to Renewables," Scientific American, April 28, 2010,